Peter Christensen’s Blog
I’m a fan of the Fail Blog, and the recent Sign Design Fail included a Google Maps StreetView link to Concord, NC, a suburb of Charlotte. They have streetview there? Apparently. I zoomed out to the entire USA and they have covered a TON of cities, many more than I would have suspected in the limited time it has been out. Apparently their data integration process is pretty streamlined to handle all that.
(click for bigness)
Programming language snobs are penny pinchers. That’s a tough sentence to write for some that just finished holding a workshop to help people learn Lisp of all languages. Why would I make such a bold, inflammatory statement? (No, not to troll. Most of the criticisms in this article are aimed at myself, based on my own actions over the last few years.) I had an unpleasant realization after listening to two excellent talks that developed this idea planted in my head by Raganwald with this post he quoted a few months ago:
“…you can count the number of games written in a purely functional style on one hand. Is it that language tinkerers are less concerned about writing real applications? That they know you can solve any problem with focused grunt work, but it’s not interesting to them? That the spark and newness of a different language is its own reward? Either way, the BASIC programmers win when it comes down to getting projects finished.”
—James Hague, Slumming with BASIC Programmers
The gist of the post is that uber-languages like Lisp, Erlang, Ruby, and even C are worlds ahead of BASIC, but somehow a group of Neanderthals put down their clubs and wiped away their drool long enough to write a slew of various and impressive computer games using BASIC. OK, he didn’t say that, his exact words were “…largely written by people with minimal programming background.” I was just translating for the language snobs out there. But then, mid-gloat, he hits them, you (even me) with that damning quote above about getting projects finished.
Thanks to everyone who attended or helped with the Chicago Lisp User Group’s Intro to Lisp Workshop! We had a great turnout (41 people!), a great facility (thanks to IIT’s Institute of Design), food and prizes (thanks to Obtiva), plus there was some Lisp too! This page will (eventually) contain links to all of the information about the workshop, but since most of it isn’t written or produced yet, this will at least give an idea of what to look forward to. All of the presentations were videotaped and those videos will eventually be online. There is also a big stack of feedback forms waiting to be collated, and some of that feedback will be put online.
Attendee Statistics - a breakdown of the programming languages and OS of choice, as well as a geographic breakdown of where attendees came from.
Funniest Comment - someone’s IM status was set to “Developing a speech impediment…”
Presentations
Book Raffle Winners
Congratulations to Luke Orland, Janet Kirsch, and (should have written down the third name) who won the following books in our registration raffle.
Gift-bag DVDs
Grant Rettke took the initiative to put together a “gift bag” DVD full of resources for people looking to learn more about Lisp development. The complete list is very long, but here is a summary:
We’re looking to make an updated version of this DVD, including the materials from the workshop. Please let me know if you’d be interested one - if there is a lot of interest, we might make another batch and mail them out for a small fee.
After-Party
After the workshop, a dozen or so people walked down to Elephant & Castle Pub and Restaurant. I didn’t go since I had a house full of beautiful women waiting for me (my wife and daughters ;-).
Sponsors
Special thanks to Kevin Taylor of Obtiva for sponsoring the food, drinks, gift DVDs, and the Practical Common Lisp prize book! Obtiva does on-site or outsourced development, and provides training in leading edge technologies.
This is an HTML version of the slides from my “Lisp Basics and Idioms” presentation at the Chicago Lisp User Group’s Intro to Lisp Workshop. It’s also videotaped but it will take a while to transfer it to digital, edit it, etc. It was a good presentation (IMHO) worth waiting for, but here’s the sneak peek (with links!).
If you want to look at the .ppt, you can download it here, but it’s pretty bare (or ugly, depending on how charitable you are), it doesn’t have as much info as the version below (no links, fewer references), and it is missing all of the good verbal ad-libbing I did when presenting. But hey, I’m not complaining if you want to see it!
***Lisp Basics and Idioms***
[UPDATED 6/3/2008: I fixed a duplicate, found some more registration forms, and updated the stats.]
We’re blogging live from the Chicago Lisp User Group’s Intro to Lisp Workshop, and (now that my presentation is done - whew!) here are some statistics on the attendees, based on our ghetto paper signin forms.
Total People: 41. Only 5 were involved in planning or presenting, and only 10 had ever been to one of our meetings.
Total Registration Forms: 25 31. This is the baseline for all of the statistics below (except How Did You Hear?) and doesn’t include Chicago Lisp members. 22 of them wanted to receive email announcements of future meetings.
Geographic Distribution:
Within Chicago - 68%
Illinois (outside Chicago) - 13%
Out of State - 19% (Madison and LaCrosse, Wisconsin, Omaha, Nebraska, and Columbus, Ohio)
People driving over 100 miles - 7
Furthest Travelers: Blaine and Scott from Omaha - 468 miles!
% Gmail Addresses: 45%
Primary Languages (% of registrants) - people could specify more than one
Java - 48%
Ruby - 39%
Python - 29%
C++ - 26%
C - 26%
Javascript - 16%
Perl - 10%
C# - 10%
Lisp - 10%
Obj-C - 6%
PHP - 6%
Bash - 3%
Erlang - 3%
VB - 3%
Fortran - 3%
Groovy - 3%
SmallTalk - 3%
Primary Operating System (% of registrants) - again, people could specify more than one
Linux - 71%
OSX - 48%
Windows - 13%
Solaris - 3%
How Did You Hear About The Workshop? (% of those who answered) - one answer, but I forgot to write it on the form so only 14 answered it.
Chicago Linux User Group - 29%
Chicago Python User Group - 14%
Chicago Ruby User Group - 29%
Other - 36%
I’ll put up Here’s an HTML version of my slideshow “Lisp Basics and Idioms” soon. I’m not sure what to do about the Macros presentation since it’s more in depth and was very interactive on screen (and we didn’t screen capture it). I video recorded the presentations but it’ll take me a while to get them off my camcorder and edit and process them. Keep your eyes here for more goodness.
My recent install guide for CLISP, Emacs, and SLIME on Windows XP was a big hit - it has had about 2000 hits and 5 sincere thanks in the comments (it even got praise from a troll!). In it I promised a similar guide for SBCL, and here it is.
The nice thing is that swapping out Common Lisp implementations within an Emacs/SLIME setup is easy, so maybe 3/4 of this guide is identical to the CLISP guide. I’ll put a disclaimer at the beginning of each section saying whether there’s anything new or whether you can skip it.
My math joke in the recap of the previous meeting turned out to be too conservative: this month, we had 22 people, double the turnout from last month! The meeting was held at the offices of CashNetUSA, and they were generous enough to provide pizza and drinks (for both drivers and transit riders ;-). There was a wireless transmitter but no connection to the internet, so Bruce B. routed us all through an ad-hoc network off his cellular wireless card. Next month’s meeting will be held there as well, and they promise to have a proper internet connection setup then!
<thankstosponsors>
CashNetUSA is looking for Ruby developers, or more accurately, great developers who know Ruby. They’re hiring at all levels of experience - check out their job listings. Thanks, CashNetUSA!
</thankstosponsors>
John Q. donated a copy of Programming Erlang to our first book raffle, which was won by Craig L. If anyone has a book they’d like to donate, please contact me so I put it in announcements for future meetings.
Intro to Lisp Workshop
There was some more discussion about the details of the Intro to Lisp Workshop on May 31. The most noteworthy decisions were:
Future Meetings
We also planned presentation topics for future meetings:
Emacs has an ancient (predating hypertext), simple, powerful documentation program called Info. It’s very difficult to find info about it online (try searching for “Info”), so here’s my beginner’s guide.
Info is an output format for the Texinfo typesetting syntax. Texinfo is used for writing documentation that can be output in multiple print and digital formats and is the official documentation format of the GNU project. Info files are strongly associated with Emacs - Emacs is the primary reader for Info files, but there is also a standalone reader. Manuals are organized into a tree of nodes, with a variety of ways to navigate between those nodes.
Info files can technically be written by hand, but it is much more common for them to be compiled from Texinfo. Many Linux/Unix distros come bundled with the TeX toolchain necessary to compile Texinfo, but Windows does not. The TeX/LaTex/Texinfo on Windows post is coming in the near future. For now, stick to precompiled .info files or go dive into TeX yourself.
Emacs ships with several Info manuals - they’re in the emacs/info folder. You can also create your own Info directory, add new manuals to the directory, and create your own manuals. This guide will walk you through the steps needed to get Emacs to find your info directory, add manuals in your directory to the main directory list, and use Info from within Emacs.
[NOTE: This guide assumes you're following the directory conventions I laid out in my previous post Installing CLISP, Emacs, and SLIME on Windows XP. It also gives you the baseline level of familiarity with Emacs to follow along here.]
I’ve recently come into possession of a damaged, non-functioning iPod Nano (Public Service Announcement: be careful how you hold your iPod when operating a urinal) that gave its body to science. After cleaning and drying it, I decided to see what was inside. I never took things apart as a kid because a) I took good care of things so they didn’t break, and b) if I couldn’t get it working again, I wouldn’t get a new one, so I didn’t risk it. First time for everything!
So here’s my photo documentary about taking my iPod Nano apart. I have no great electrical skills so I didn’t bother trying to fix it; I just wanted to see how it was put together and what was inside.
[DISCLAIMER: The thumbnails were automatically generated by WordPress and therefore not always centered or cropped the way I would like. Click on each image for larger and more complete images.]
First, a front and back view of the iPod:
Until this week, I had been putting off setting up a CL/Emacs/SLIME environment from scratch ever since I had trouble getting ASDF to work with Lispbox. Every time I tried, I ran into some will-sapping problem like needing to find a good Windows program for .tar.gz files, or finding the command line flags to get CLISP to run right, or figuring out the best way to setup a folder structure that matches the Unix folders used by most Lispers. Every time I fixed one problem, I ran into another. For someone out there trying to do a setup like this, there are lots of good resources, but they are either incomplete or outdated.
For instance, the Common Lisp Cookbook has a very thorough page on Setting Up an IDE with Emacs on Windows or Max OSX, but as far as I can tell, it’s from 2004 or earlier because it doesn’t mention SBCL or SLIME, two of the most popular pieces of CL development software today. Or when you run into a specific problem, it’s usually not too hard to find an answer, but it might not match the setup you’re using. That’s why I had to quit using Lispbox, because no one had any clue how it was configured, especially not on Windows. n00bs didn’t know the answers and the wizards had a traditional setup.
Here are some of the variables that contribute to the combinatorial explosion of configuration, in order or pain caused:
Maybe someday someone will try out all of those combinations and report, but for today, I did exactly one: Windows XP, CLISP 2.44, SLIME CVS, and Emacs 22.2 Why CLISP? After reading lots of internet, I came to the conclusion that (aside from the commercial CLs), CLISP is the best implementation for Windows users. The knocks against it are that it’s slow because it’s byte-code compiled, it doesn’t have threads, and on some points, it’s ideologically different from CL and other implementations.
Well, the performance isn’t a big concern for me (plus as I went to press, 2.45 was released with experimental JIT compilation), the threads also aren’t a big deal right now, and I think the differences will help me be aware of the considerations for writing portable code. Also regarding the SBCL windows port, it’s still considered experimental (currently v1.013 for Windows) but people are saying it’s stable and everything works except the threads. There’s even an msi installer for the Windows version. One of my next projects will be to dive into the SBCL documentation and mailing lists to get a better feel for it.
As far as the philosophy behind this (and future) setup guides, I want them to be a) thorough and b) instructive. Instructive? If you just want to take my word for everything, that’s fine, but I want you to know where I got my info from, so I’ve tried to include links to references for each step. On to the setup guide!
